eBay Returns for New Sellers: How to Set a Return Policy and Handle Requests

Every eBay seller gets returns. Handling them well protects your account and your reputation. This guide explains how to set an eBay return policy for sellers and how to respond when a buyer asks to return an item.
Choosing your return policy
- Return window: eBay offers set options. A longer window can build buyer confidence.
- Who pays return shipping: free returns can attract buyers but add cost. Include this in your pricing.
- Category rules: some categories and situations have their own requirements, so check eBay’s current return settings.
Two kinds of returns
- Change of mind: the buyer no longer wants the item. Your policy decides how this is handled.
- Not as described: the item differs from the listing or is faulty. Under eBay’s Money Back Guarantee, buyers are generally protected here, whatever your policy says.
How to handle a return request
- Reply quickly and politely. Ask for photos if the problem is unclear.
- Offer a solution: return for refund, replacement or, where appropriate, a partial refund.
- Follow eBay’s return process so the case is recorded correctly.
- Inspect the item when it arrives and refund on time.
How to keep returns low
- Describe condition honestly and show defects in photos.
- Include exact measurements and compatibility details.
- Pack items carefully to avoid damage.
- Avoid products with known quality problems, even if margins look high.
Price returns into your profit
When you calculate profit, set aside a small amount for returns and refunds. A product that only works if nobody ever returns it is not a good product.
We cover return settings and buyer cases in the Certified Specialist Program. Read next: eBay fees explained for beginners.
Setting a returns policy that protects you
- Decide who pays return postage. Free returns can attract buyers, but international return costs from abroad to Pakistan can be high. Price this in or consider offering a refund without return for low-value items.
- Describe items accurately. Most “not as described” returns come from unclear sizes, colours or condition notes.
- Inspect returned items and photograph their condition when they arrive.
- Respond quickly to return requests to avoid the case escalating to eBay.
- Track the reasons. If many returns mention the same issue, fix the listing.
Remember that even with a “no returns” setting, buyers can still open a case if an item is not as described, so accuracy is your best protection.
Related guides: Message templates · Performance standards
More eBay guides
- eBay Fees Explained for Beginners: What You Pay and How to Price
- eBay Seller Performance Standards: Top Rated, Above Standard and Below Standard
- Shipping eBay Orders from Pakistan: Couriers, Customs and Handling Time
- How to Write eBay Listings That Sell: Titles, Photos and Item Specifics
- eBay Feedback: How to Earn Positive Feedback and Handle Negative Reviews
- Is an eBay Store Subscription Worth It? A Guide for New Sellers
- eBay Customer Service: Message Templates for Common Buyer Questions